Sally Clark, the solictor wrongly imprisoned between 1999 and 2003 for the murder of both her young sons, died this morning, according to BBC News.
Her conviction, and subsequent acquittal, became very famous in the UK, particular because of some of the statistics offered by an expert witness, Sir Roy Meadow. Meadow’s evidence was, basically, that the chance of both of Sally Clark’s sons dying of natural causes was so slim, that one had to assume that they were murdered. The structure of his argument was as follows:
- The chance of a randomly chosen child dying or Sids (Sudden Infant Death Syndome, popularly known as cot death) is about 1 in 3000.
- Amongst non-smoking, older parents, with at least one wage, this rises to about 1 in 8500.
- The chance of both Sally Clark’s sons dying of Sids is about 1 in 8500×8500, or 1 in 73 million.
- The chance that the two boys were not murdered is 1 in 73 million.